History in Politics – The Fairest Tax

By Neil Rolde

Governor Paul LePage of Maine says he wants to eliminate Maine taxes, which would devastate thousands and the state's economy. Courtesy photo

Governor Paul LePage of Maine says he wants to eliminate Maine taxes, which would devastate thousands and the state’s economy. Courtesy photo

Maine’s bomb-throwing and wrecker Governor Paul Le Page has a new trick up his sleeve. He now proposes doing away with Maine’s State Income Tax. Installed in the late 1960’s, this major source of State revenue [at least 50 percent of the budget] has provided an irreplaceable foundation of Maine’s economy for more than half a century.

What does the bully boy in the Blaine House offer to put in its place? Apparently nothing!

Cuts, of course, will have to be made in State services. Le Page’s draconian knife no doubt will slash first and foremost at social programs helping the poor from whose ranks he came but whose plight no longer touches him. Indeed, he seems annoyed by their continued presence. He rose above poverty. Why can’t they? And if they can’t, tant pis, which means “all the worse” for them in French.

Actually, doing away with the Maine State Income Tax has been tried before. Shortly after it was enacted, a “people’s veto” was attempted to nullify its going into law – a statewide election forced by petition to repeal what the Legislature had voted.

Currently supporters of Le Page’s action are arguing that Maine people should have a chance to express whether they want the Fairest Tax or not, one based on ability to pay or to revert to reliance on our two major regressive taxes – the sales tax and the property tax. Regressive, by the way, signifies a policy that hits the poor and middle classes – the vast bulk of Maine residents – the hardest. The less you have to pay with, the more you have to pay percentage wise.

As for a statewide referendum on this issue, we have been there, done that.

And an amazing thing happened. All the political pundits and especially the media were crowing that the Income Tax was doomed. Given the chance to vote on a tax, Mainers would surely get rid of it by an overwhelming margin.

Yet when the votes closed and the ballots were counted, the result was astounding. Not only was the repeal measure defeated, it was crushed by a tally of 3-1, an incredible show of support for the Fairest Tax.

In the interests of full disclosure, I was a charter member and spokesman for the anti-repeal organization called FAIR – Fight Against Income Tax Repeal. Our message was clear. If one of the three pillars of the State’s tax structure was removed, Maine would revert to the stagnant backward-looking economy it had suffered since the latter part of the 19th century.

Or if attempts were made of necessity to increase the other two taxes to fill the holes left in the State budget, the cost hikes were estimated and they were breathtaking.

Yes, we know that underlying Le Page’s lack of discussion of the consequences of his restless attack on the State’s financial status quo, certain services now available will be ravaged or even totally curtailed. Social services, of course. What else? Education is a major expense but a necessity. Back to the property tax exclusively for that. The Environment. Can we afford to despoil it? Tourism is the major industry in today’s Maine. Will vistors flock to see devastated forests and endure polluted waters?

I have always admired the common sense and fair-mindedness of Maine people.

Over the generations, they have generated a wonderful expression I love.

“If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.”

When it comes to Governor Le Pages’s so-called Fix, let’s just say No, thanks, to his rush to make Maine into Mississippi.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s